The Debate: Chlorine vs. Saltwater Pools?

The Debate: Chlorine vs. Saltwater Pools?


If you're a pool owner, you’ve likely heard or even had the debate: chlorine or saltwater pools?

With summer looming in the distance, Spring is the perfect time to weigh the pros and cons! Offering ample time for making the switch, especially if you’re considering upgrades or planning for a new pool.

Both systems aim to keep your water safe for swimmers.

However, how they work, what they cost, and how they affect your pool long-term are very different.

Let's dive in!

Chlorine Pools

Pros:  Lower upfront installation costs, where additional equipment is not required.

→ Effectively killing algae, bacteria, and contaminants. Available as a liquid, tablet, or granule. 

→ Familiar maintenance routine for most pool owners and service professionals. Traditional treatment method within your weekly routine.

→ Works with any pool size, shape, or surface without major equipment changes.

Cons:

→ Can cause skin, eye, and hair irritation if levels are not properly maintained.

→ Chlorine smell can be strong, especially after heavy use. 

Long-term chemical costs can add up over the life of the pool.

Saltwater Pools

Pros:  Gentler on skin, eyes, and swimwear due to lower liquid chlorine concentrations.

→ Automatic chlorine generation means less daily chemical handling.

→ Water feels softer and less harsh, offering a more comfortable swimming experience.

Lower long-term chemical costs compared to traditional chlorine pools.

Cons: 

→ Salt can be corrosive to pool equipment, metal fixtures, and decking if not managed properly.

→ Salt cells require regular cleaning and eventual replacement.

→ Higher upfront costs for the salt system and repairs.

What’s the Best Fit for You?

Consider:
→ Your comfort with regular chemical management?
→ Your budget for long-term maintenance?
→ How much time you have to spend on maintenance?
→ The materials your pool and equipment are made from?

Both systems can keep your pool clean, healthy, and ready for the season, but they require different approaches. Choosing the right one starts with understanding what you want out of your pool experience.

No matter which system you choose, regular care and chemistry balancing are the number one keys to ensuring your pool stays clean, clear, and ready for the Summer season!